The Training Network - NHS - GPs - A bit closer to the fire...

A bit closer to the fire…

It’s the Treasury… all their fault.

Actually, the Treasury is only a building.  It’s been around for a long time.  Since 1240.  In 1698, it burned down when a servant aired bed linen too close to the fire.

Replaced in 1734, and got bombed in 1940. 

The public seldom get a chance to see the ‘The Drum’, the internal, elegant courtyard, whose provenance is to be found in designs by the architect Palladio.

The staircase is impressive but much of the wide open interiors were boxed-off, into offices and 580 fire places ripped out.

Despite its history, it only manages a Grade ll listing despite another make-over in 2002.  In 1990, the, then, Chancellor, Norman Lamont, likened the Treasury’s ambiance to a Russian psychiatric hospital.  After the make-over, he said it was like a Marriott hotel.

Whatever… it’s only a building, so when someone says ‘the Treasury don’t agree‘, what they really mean is; somebody, we don’t know who, doesn’t agree.

I don’t like that.  I’m happy when decisions go for, or against, something that I would champion, provided I get a well reasoned argument.  Maybe I don’t agree but don’t treat me like an idiot.  I can make a fool of myself without any outside help, thank you!

Right now the NHS is facing a huge problem created by ‘The Treasury’ and it is a problem for a group of people who are not attracting much sympathy.  The group are high-end-paid doctors.

People earning over £100k don’t get us weeping tears of sympathy but they have a huge problem and it has become a problem for us all.  People for whom we would shed tears of sympathy.

The problem?   Some medics are facing unexpected tax bills of over £80,000.

People saving for retirement benefit from tax relief on what is paid into, or saved-up, in a pension, subject to annual and lifetime limits. The standard annual allowance is £40,000, which is more than adequate for most average earners.

Pension savings in excess of the allowance face a tax charge, payable at the same rate as an individual’s rate of income tax.

However, in 2016, new curbs were introduced on tax relief for the UK’s top earners who benefit from the lion’s share of government incentives for pension saving.

The so-called, tapered-annual-allowance gradually reduces the annual allowance from £40,000 to just £10,000 for the very highest earners.

Complex rules, governing how the taper is applied, coupled with the inflexibility of the NHS pension scheme, where individuals have little control over their employer’s contributions, have led to thousands of staff, doctors, nurses and senior managers, receiving a tax penalty – often as the result of taking on extra shifts to help manage the workforce crisis in the Service.

The Treasury need to fix it because the up-shot is, consultants are reluctant to take on waiting list work, or fill rota gaps, because they can end up not only earning next to nothing but actually falling into tax penalty.

Trust employers are being encouraged, by the DH+, to use what are little more than clunky fiddles, to get around the rules… and that is hardly an ethical, long-term solution.

The real solution is ‘The Treasury’… the rules have to be changed.  

Understandably doctors are not going to pay the NHS to do a shift and there are over four million, of our fellow citizens, waiting for elective treatment.  

Some will die before they can take their turn.  There are rota gaps for senior clinicians that make some care dangerously under doctored.

There is a saying; two things are certain, death and taxes… it’s not, death because of taxes.

The Treasury is only a building.  The Chancellor of the Exchequer is Sajid Javid, a man seeking election.  The First Lord of the Treasury is the Prime Minister, also looking to keep his job.

Forget holding the linen too close to the fire, there are some people’s feet that need to be held a bit closer to the fire.

Have a good weekend.

News and Comment from Roy Lilley

Contact Roy – please use this e-address roy.lilley@nhsmanagers.net

Reproduced at thetrainingnet.com by kind permission of Roy Lilley.

Previous Posts

A wooden bench on a grassy area overlooks a large body of water, with mountains visible in the hazy background.

Headline.

Streeting’s latest NHS workforce plan ignores systemic issues, focusing on recruiting more GPs despite the strain on resources. The real solution? Shifting care to community nurses, who offer better value and flexibility.

Read More »
A modern white hospital building with multiple windows stands in front of a taller white skyscraper, under a blue sky with clouds, partially obscured by a green hedge.

Think again.

Think “hospital,” and you picture nurses, ambulances, or stethoscopes—not someone hunched over a desk solving the NHS equivalent of a mathematical enigma. Yet, administrators are its hidden heroes.

Read More »
A man sits on a gray couch, talking on his smartphone while engaging with his laptop, the backdrop of a brick wall emphasizing the modern workspace vibe—a scene possibly oriented towards primary care training for GPs.

Forever!

I’m sitting at the computer screen, wondering if it’s worth taking up your time. Charmer’s speech yesterday—three commitments, five missions, six milestones—offered no clarity, just a rat’s nest of priorities.

Read More »
A woman sits cross-legged on a rocky riverbank, meditating with her eyes closed. She wears a white top and gray pants, much like medical staff in moments of calm between responsibilities, surrounded by greenery and the soothing flow of the river.

Fat chance!

Health Secretary Wes Streeting faces ridicule over a ban on sugary food ads before 9 PM, accused of ‘nanny-state’ tactics while failing to address deeper causes of childhood obesity.

Read More »
A doctor holding a large hourglass is surrounded by medical graphics, illustrating NHS capacity and patient inflow, highlighting the critical role of GP training in navigating a hospital's dynamic environment.

It might just be possible!

Ancient China’s gifts include silk, spices, and calculus. Applied to the NHS, calculus explains how waiting lists grow due to inefficiencies. Fixing productivity, not just efficiency, is key to improvement.

Read More »
A yellow and black butterfly with intricate patterns rests on a plant amid green foliage, offering a moment of tranquility reminiscent of nature's gentle touch in healing settings like those embraced by dedicated NHS doctors.

Butterfly.

The NHS faces chaos as budget cuts and aging demographics collide, with ambulance services reducing capacity amid rising demand. Like the butterfly effect, small decisions now amplify systemic crises.

Read More »
Lindsay Dubock stands at the front of the room, addressing a seated audience with dynamic insights in a conference setting. Engaging slides from The Training Network illuminate behind her, enhancing the training experience.

The General Practice Toolkit

Lindsay delivered The General Practice Toolkit to over 100 NHS Primary Care delegates at Bromley Court Hotel, equipping them with practical strategies to enhance mental health, resilience, and holistic patient care.

Read More »
A rainy city street with a dome-topped cathedral in the background is surrounded by tall buildings. Amidst the bustle of black cabs and red buses, doctors hurrying to provide primary care walk alongside others with umbrellas on the slick pavement.

Put your money on them. 

Drivers spend two days a year waiting at red lights. Meanwhile, 4.2 million UK people claim health-related benefits. Tackling these challenges? Focus on trust-building, holistic care, and our GPs.

Read More »