This tells me, central to a settlement, is a refresh of the Agenda for Change pay scales.

Talk first

If you or yours were expecting to get some long awaited treatment underway, you might be disappointed…

…176 places of NHS work, out of the 311 where ballots were held, are walking out.

Look out for a letter, or text, or something.

The RCN know what they’re doing. They’re going on strike 15th and 20th December. Where, they are yet to disclose.

In the middle of one of the worst, pressured times I can remember, in 50yrs of NHS watching.

Two week-days that will ricochet through the months to come.

Trusts have known it’s coming. By-and-large they have good relations with local union representatives. They have the dates and can finesse their plans.

Now what?

Bully-Boy says his ‘door is open’…

Good?

No, bad…

…first, it means he will meet people on his territory…

…second, he has the luxury of ‘the door’ and…

…third he can decide when to open and close it.

It’s a phrase right out of the lexicon of the bully-boss. All too common… powerful people take power for granted.

It’s a copout.

Makes BB feel righteous and puts the onus on the RCN. Proper negotiating must be in good faith, on equal terms.

This dispute will not be ended by an offer of more money, alone. It’ll be determined by public opinion.

An unpopular government, versus the very people we all clapped for, a year or so ago.

Or…

An unpopular strike and a fine way for the people we clapped for, to replay us.

Take yer-pick.

The tabloids and Sky TV, are already fishing for patients disappointed, distressed or disadvantaged by strikes… to tell their stories.

The arguments need to be fine tuned.

The RCN should be saying; this is about the two R’s. Reinstating the pay nurses have lost and safe Rotas, for patients and their families.

HMG have to press the money argument, on a public already pressed for money; the nurses claim will cost billions we don’t have and we are recruiting more nurses.

The actual cost of the claim? Seventeen or more percent on top of what nurses earn.

What do they earn?

Beware! This is tricky and I suspect, where the rows will begin.

There are several ways to present the figures. You be the judge.

There are eight pay bands, one having four sub-bands, each having a number of progression points.

For example; a Band 5 (entry level nurse), starts at £27,055, after two years they can progress to £29,180 and after a further two years to the top-step, £32,934.

The Agenda for Change pay scales are complex, cover more than nurses and depend on the employer paying the right band for the job… and some of them have craftily, been de-banding.

Taking an average of each of the eight bands, in total and importantly, with average progression, bearing in mind the majority of nurses are between 31-40yrs and will have progressed, it can be argued…

… the average pay of a nurse might be £49, 965.

However, that includes Band 9 nurses who have probably long since swapped regular bed-pan emptying, for pressing delete on a computer.

It also includes Bands 2,3 and 4 who are actually, healthcare support workers.

Their average income is £22,787.

For around a minimum wage, they carry out vital, skilful work including; bathing, observations, wound-care, blood samples and other care, often above their grades. Others are drivers, administrators, domestic and estate workers none of which will be members of the RCN…

… more likely Unison, who are balloting.

If we exclude Bands 9, 2,3 and 4…

… the average pay of a nurse might be £54,564.

But, look at the majority of frontline nurses who work between Bands 5,6 and 7 and…

… the average pay for a nurse might be £37,268.

(Just 5 and 6 and the average is £33,570)

Finally, the top earners; Bands 8a,b,c,d and 9 and …

… the average pay of a nurse might be £74,849.

For context, the ONS tell us the national average salary for someone in full-time work is £38,131…

…now you can see how deceptive averages can be and don’t forget over 10yrs overall, nursing pay has seen inflation erode incomes by 20%.

With a similar health warning; the Graduate Outcomes report by The Higher Education Statistics Agency, says the current average graduate salary in the UK is just over £24,000.

This tells me, central to a settlement, is a refresh of the Agenda for Change pay scales.

Maybe, even a differential settlement that favours Bands 5 and 6?

A deal might look like the RCN to agreeing to;

• have a say in the upcoming workforce plan,
• a downpayment increase for Bands 5-6 now and
• a further payment next year, across the board.
• Outlaw de-banding.
• A forgiveness of student debt, would cost nothing and
• something around meals, childcare, travel and parking costs…

… would make a big difference.

All disputes end in discussions.

‘My door is open…’ says; I’m only prepared to make minimal effort.

‘My door is open…’ sounds like; door’s open, mind’s closed.

‘My door is open…’ speaks volumes about; ‘don’t bother unless you’ve something to tell me I will like.’

Cunningly, whispered, sotto-voche; go and annoy the public…

… then we’ll see who has to talk first.

News and Comment from Roy Lilley
Contact Roy – please use this e-address roy.lilley@nhsmanagers.net
Reproduced at thetrainingnet.com by kind permission of Roy Lilley.


Discover more from The Training Network

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Previous Posts

A working mother sits in her parked car outside a UK care home, overcome with emotion after visiting her mother with dementia while balancing work and family responsibilities. Andy Burnham social care reform

Answers

Andy Burnham’s social care reforms promise fairness for families, but funding alone cannot solve workforce shortages, capacity constraints or NHS integration. After seventeen years, voters deserve detailed answers, not aspirations.

Read More »
Modern NHS regional health authority headquarters with staff entering the main reception, illustrating regional NHS leadership and healthcare system management. NHS missing middle

The Missing Middle

Roy Lilley argues the NHS needs to restore a powerful regional tier, creating a functional middle between Whitehall and local providers to improve planning, accountability, delivery and long-term resilience.

Read More »
Care worker assisting an elderly resident using a walking frame in a residential care home corridor in England. social care funding reform

Paid for

Louise Casey’s call for another national conversation on social care echoes Andy Burnham’s 2009 consultation. The evidence already exists; what remains absent is political courage to decide funding.

Read More »
Patients, visitors and NHS staff entering the main entrance of a large NHS general hospital during a routine weekday. NHS waiting list management

The truth

Political promises alone cannot reduce NHS waiting lists. Sustainable improvement depends on matching ambition with workforce, capacity, operational planning, transparent reporting and honest leadership rather than headline-grabbing announcements.

Read More »
House of Commons during a parliamentary debate, viewed from the back of the chamber with ministers facing rows of MPs. Andy Burnham Labour MPs letter

Their way

Andy Burnham’s letter to Labour MPs signals a different philosophy of government, but unless power genuinely shifts from Whitehall, it risks becoming another exercise in consultation rather than meaningful reform.

Read More »
Senior NHS leader speaking at a podium as overcrowded GP consulting rooms contrast with empty office space, illustrating conflicting messages about NHS estate capacity. Penny Dash primary care estate

New ones

Penny Dash’s latest comments on primary care estate capacity expose a fundamental contradiction at the heart of NHS policy, raising fresh questions about leadership, evidence, investment and neighbourhood healthcare delivery.

Read More »
The St George's Cross flag of England billows dramatically in the wind against a bright blue sky with scattered white clouds, symbolising English identity, pride and national heritage. NHS leadership and organisational culture

Play

Roy Lilley explores what football leadership can teach the NHS, arguing that lasting success comes not from targets or tactics alone, but from trust, culture, relationships and permission.

Read More »
A satirical street-market display imagines Andy Burnham's journey to Downing Street, complete with campaign merchandise and five proposed NHS reforms. Andy Burnham NHS reform

Feel-the-Burn

Andy Burnham’s route to Downing Street should begin with five practical NHS reforms: devolve power, fund patient journeys, modernise digitally, empower regions and build an NHS that anticipates problems.

Read More »